Category Archives: Transport IQ Trainwrecks

A process problem with the trains…

Information can take many forms. Ultimately, it is the ‘message’ that is communicated between two people (or systems or processes).

This story from today’s Irish Examiner shows the importance of checking that the message being communicated is accurate and timely. It’s a trainwreck because it relates to trains, there was a problem and it will cost the Irish rail operator €10,000 to compensate people for a miscommunication and an error in the presentation of information.

The summary of the article is that

  1. Over 300 people were waiting for the train from one of Ireland’s flagship railway stations.
  2. A visually impaired passenger was helped by the Station Controller on to the train
  3. The signal for the train to depart was given, while 300+ people stood on the platform.
  4. The people at the station had to take a different train (leading no doubt to over crowding), which made an unscheduled stop to link up with a special shuttle train transfer that brought them to their final destination.

Inaccurate information was given to the train driver and guard (or perhaps they interpreted information incorrectly) who followed the procedure when that signal was given – they started the train up and left the platform (and the 300 people) behind it.
How might this have been avoided? As ever in these cases an investigation is underway.

ahem… Information Quality problem with the trains…

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/11/13/eurostar_glitch/

Again culled from el Reg, here’s an example of an information quality problem that prevents a process (a very trivial process) from being completed.

It seems that the on-line booking system for the EuroStar train linking the UK with Europe doesn’t recognise the existence of the 29th of February 2008. As the leap year day is the day when women can traditionally propose to their partners (as opposed to dropping less and less subtle hints about the need for a big diamond on their finger which happens the other 3 years out of 4) this might pose a problem for some.

Why is this an IQ Trainwreck?…

  • Well, it involves trains so it is just too easy an association to make.
  • A process has been (apologies for this one) derailed by poor quality information (or master data or a poorly designed/implemented data quality check)
  • The comments from the readers of the post sum up the likely responses of people encountering the problem..
    • This is a trivial bug, if that’s how careless they are do I really want to travel by train?
    • They obviously don’t want my business, I’ll fly instead
    • Good grief…. how embarassing for them.

Apparently the Eurostar site isn’t the only one to have this issue… but it is the one that makes the best IQ Trainwreck.