Category Archives: Financial Services IQ Trainwrecks

Leap Year problem hits Irish bank

The Sunday Business Post newspaper (Ireland’s leading weekly paper dedicated to business news) carried a story this week about errors in calculating mortgage interest due to the 2008 Leap Year which have affected at least one Irish bank. This is an information quality problem we discussed previously on this blog.Of course, the bank’s are simply going to apply the interest missed out to the customer’s accounts retrospectively, with the average additional charge to customers being around €28.50, according to reports. However, the fact that this error has appeared in the national media, and the Halifax’s competitors are all stating that they have had no such problems, suggests that the cost to the bank may be greater in terms of negative PR. In this case the bank made a gross error in defining its information architecture and the core business rules for interest calculations (such as assuming 2008 was not a leap year), and it would seem their systems testing failed to catch the problem until after the event. However, as is often the case, the cost of non-quality information is being passed to the customer, making the immediate ‘problem’ go away (a shortfall in interest payments and profits) while masking the underlying root cause (failure to properly define and test information processing rules for core processes resulting in poor quality information). 

Irish bank sends debtor details to wrong addresses

The Irish Examiner reports today that a leading Irish bank accidentally sent details on defaulted loans to the wrong address. Two letters were sent to the one address – which was the wrong one. The contents of the letters contained the correct name and address information for the account holders (it appears from the media report).

This echoes an issue the same bank had in November of last year when 11,000 letters containing confidential bank details were sent to the wrong addresses.

While this most recent issue relates to just two letters relating to two customers. But the real mystery is how they both wound up at the same address.

Another error from a wunch of bankers…

The Register has this interesting story… a man in Georgia USA received a letter from his bank shortly after he closed his account with them. He believed he had cleared any outstanding charges so was a little bit surprised when he received a letter from the bank insisting he owed them $211 trillion dollars. This is just over 23 times the national debt of the United States (as at 4th Dec 2007).

The letter received by the unfortunate man also informed him that the information regarding his debt would be passed to a credit scoring agency. As this is apparently an automated process the ex-account holder has resigned himself to it appearing on his credit report at some point in the future.

The bank has apologised and has assured the recipient that his details have not been passed on. The bank’s stated root cause for this error was a “word processing error” (how quaint, they seem to still write each individual letter by hand. No mail merge?) and that this was an isolated case.

There is no information whether the poor recipient of this letter has considered suing the bank for the shock and awe that their letter may have caused, or the potential damage to his credit rating if the bank bungles the fix of their bungling.

At $211 trillion dollars this counts as a trainwreck, and is the counterbalance to the story we had a while ago about the Australian man and his uncontrolled overdraft.