RTE News in Ireland ran a story last night on overcharging by Irish Life Assurance companies arising from a mis-classification of customers as smokers. (link to the item is here, but you may not be able to access it if you are not in Ireland).

On foot of two complaints, the Irish Financial Services Ombudsman investigated two companies and has identified up to 500 customers affected.  However more customers may be affected in other companies .

The two companies affected blamed “computer and administrative errors” for the misclassification and the resulting overcharging. In other words, an Information Quality problem.

The financial impact for the two customers who complained was between €1100 and €2500 on policies of different lengths. Taking a crude average value, this would suggest that for the 500 cases the Ombudsman suspects in the two companies he looked at the total cost of refunds will be in the order of €900,000.

The cost of the investigation of possible errors and the correction of records would, of course, be on top of this amount.

The Financial Services Obmudsman has asked the Irish Financial Services Regulator to conduct an industry wide audit of all Life Assurance companies to identify further instances of this kind of overcharging based on misclassification of customers. As a result, the total amount of refunds will inevitably rise, as will the cost to the industry of inaccurate information.

The news report makes no mention of the potential Data Protection issues arising here under Irish Data Protection law, which does require information to be kept accurate and up to date. But the Irish Financial Ombudsman used to be the Data Protection Commissioner, so I am sure he has flagged that to the affected institutions himself.